MHR Home Search MHR Order Customer Care What's New @ MHR About MHR Feedback
McGraw-Hill Ryerson Home Elementary & Secondary Education Home
  Rep Locator Contact Us Site Map Search   Advanced Search  
Grades Grades Subjects Subjects Parents Parents Students Students Teachers Teachers Booksites Booksites Authors Authors Apprenticeship Apprenticeship Imprints Imprints About Us About Us
 []Shopping Cart

Subjects
Advanced Placement
Business
English
Family Studies
Fine Arts
Health and Physical Education
History and Social Sciences
Mathematics
Science
   
MHR Home > School > Mathematics > Student Tips > Guessing vs. Estimating    

Mathematics Student Tips

header_line_purple.gif

Guessing vs. Estimating


About how many recordings are played by the radio stations in Ontario in a day?

Rich estimation problems like this one are also known as Fermi problems. They are named after Enrico Fermi (1901-1954). He was a leading research scientist, who won the Nobel Prize for physics in 1938 and spent the last part of his career as a professor at the University of Chicago. He liked to show his students that they had the knowledge to answer seemingly impossible questions that he posed.

The importance of Fermi problems is to illustrate the difference between guessing and estimation. Although guessing may produce a reasonable answer to a problem, you do not now how much confidence to place in the answer. When estimating the answers to Fermi problems, you will need to make some assumptions. If the estimated answer seems to be unreasonable, go back and check your assumptions.

About how many peanuts in the shell would be needed to fill a telephone booth?

Understand the Problem

  1. What information are you given?
  2. What are you asked to find?
  3. Do you need an exact or an approximate answer?

Think of a Plan

The problem is a volume problem, in which you need to estimate how many small objects are needed to fill a large object. The number of small objects, n, can be found using:

n = (large volume) ÷ (small volume)

Carry Out the Plan

You can use your research skills to find that the inside of a telephone booth approximates a square-based prism. The side length of the base is about 0.9 m, and the height is about 1.9 m.

Assume the peanuts in a shell approximate a cylinder with a diameter of about 1.5 cm and a height of about 4 cm.

The volume of a telephone booth, in cubic centimetres, is about 90 x 90 x 190, or about 1 540 000 cm3.

The volume of peanuts in the shell, in cubic centimetres, is about p x 0.752 x 4, or about 7 cm 3.

So, n = 1 540 000 ÷ 7

= 220 000

About 2220 000 peanuts in the shell would be needed to fill a telephone booth.

Look Back

Does the answer seem reasonable?

Is there a way to improve the estimate?

In summary, to solve Rich Estimation Problems, follow these steps:

  1. Locate the information you need.
  2. Decide what assumption(s) to make.
  3. Estimate the solution to the problem.
  4. Check that your estimate is reasonable.

MathPower 10

 
McGraw-Hill Education (Site opens in a new window) Privacy Notice - Terms of Use The McGraw-Hill Companies (Site opens in a new window)